Parenting Question

September 14, 2021

Should I let my child go on a residential trip?

Should I let my child go on a residential trip?

My child in Year 5 is about to go on a two-day residential with their school. I am very worried about this. Should I even let them go?

Being away from our children can trigger a lot of nervous emotion and, for some parents, it can cause anxiety. It is perfectly normal to worry about an anticipated separation and, in the time of a global pandemic, our feelings about being at home, at school, at work and away from one another can be a little bit all over the place.  When I read this question, it reminded me of the time, two years ago, that we asked our 10 year old to post a letter, on a solo trip down a busy road. We sent him off with a brisk wave and confidently shut the door. My husband then spent the next ten minutes pacing the hallway, peering out the window and wondering if his instructions about crossing the road were clear enough. Some fifteen minutes later, our son arrived home with his chest puffed out, whistling to himself and keen to tell us all about the cat he’d met on his short journey. We appeared nonplussed, calm and asked him if he would like to post some letters again tomorrow. “Sure!” he replied. 

Being away from our children can trigger a lot of nervous emotion and, for some parents, it can cause anxiety. It is perfectly normal to worry about an anticipated separation and, in the time of a global pandemic, our feelings about being at home, at school, at work and away from one another can be a little bit all over the place.

When I read this question, it reminded me of the time, two years ago, that we asked our 10 year old to post a letter, on a solo trip down a busy road. We sent him off with a brisk wave and confidently shut the door. My husband then spent the next ten minutes pacing the hallway, peering out the window and wondering if his instructions about crossing the road were clear enough. Some fifteen minutes later, our son arrived home with his chest puffed out, whistling to himself and keen to tell us all about the cat he’d met on his short journey. We appeared nonplussed, calm and asked him if he would like to post some letters again tomorrow. “Sure!” he replied.

The purpose of telling you this story is to emphasise that, as hard it might feel, we have to exercise our children’s ‘independence muscle’; giving them little opportunities to feel ‘grown up’. In doing so, we boost their self-esteem and their own belief in their ability to cope. Never before have these mini opportunities to practise resilience been so important. Our children have been denied social contact, time with family and access to group play for a significant part of last year. We need to make that up. We need to get back on the horse. It can feel like tearing off a plaster, but it is essential for their wellbeing moving forward.

Researchers in the mental health community have been lobbying for children to return to both school and play for some time. Within academic literature, they have also been urging schools to amplify the opportunities children have to spend time together in ways that they missed out on during lockdowns. A residential trip gives your lucky child an opportunity to be with their peers, their teachers and practise life without you for two days. It could otherwise be called ‘resilience training’. I am afraid to say, whilst I completely understand why parents might feel anxious about stayaways, the truth is, over-protective parenting is correlated with poor mental health in adulthood. If you don’t believe me, listen to our interview with Professor Siobhan O’Neill in Tooled Up. Our interview with former Researcher of the MonthProfessor Helen Dodd, also points to fact that often anxious parents are less likely to promote autonomy in their children, and may need to work hard to allow children to take part in activities that involve a little risk (tree climbing is one such example). Watch our video in the Tooled Up library on the importance of play for more information on this point.

The most resilient children, the children who adapt and cope well with later transitions, are those whose parents send them off with a positive wave and a confident heart. If children witness parental anxiety ahead of a transition of this kind, they are inclined to absorb the message that “something horrible might happen to me”, or “I don’t have the skills to deal with this”. Instead, imagine how wonderful they will feel about themselves, when they return off the school bus, full of tales about all the things they did, the fun they had.

As you prepare for their trip, try not to do the packing for them. Let them practise following the school packing guidance and give them some agency in this process. Don’t make too much of a fuss by asking questions such as “do you think you will be ok?” or suggesting you could pick them up if they have had enough. Trust their teachers and have confidence in your child.

After the trip and on pick up, your role will be to help them reflect on the fact that they may have felt a little bit nervous beforehand, but they went and had a ball! Reflection breeds resilience. For more on this point, listen to our interview within Tooled Up with Professor Tamsin Ford (Professor of Psychiatry at Cambridge University).

Schools, you can help parents ahead of residentials by giving them as much information as possible about the daily schedule and by letting teddies attend too (but don’t encourage notes from parents as these can often disrupt children’s coping strategies and may trigger anxiety). Updating a daily blog with pictures of happy, smiling children can massively reassure parents and grandparents waiting nervously at home.

More Parenting Questions

What do we need to consider when thinking about hiring a tutor?

Dec 18, 2024

What do we need to consider when thinking about hiring a tutor?

Private tutoring can be a great way to support your child's education, but finding the right person can also feel overwhelming. The tutoring industry is largely unregulated in the UK and so it can be challenging to know where to start or what to look for.

My 11 year old daughter is always hungry. Should I be concerned?

Oct 22, 2024

My 11 year old daughter is always hungry. Should I be concerned?

This is a common concern for many parents. Engaged and attentive parents are generally mindful of their child’s relationship with food.   This is not surprising given the shameful narrative surrounding the idea of being overweight or obese, and the association that is often made that this is linked to neglectful parenting.

Should I let my child attend sex education lessons at primary school?

Oct 15, 2024

Should I let my child attend sex education lessons at primary school?

First of all, try not to beat yourself about your decision (you obviously love your child and want the best for them), but I would ask you to think about the motivations behind your decision carefully. Sometimes in parenting, what feels like ‘doing the right’ thing might inadvertently put a child at greater risk.

How can I best support my son with changes to his class next year?

Jun 03, 2024

How can I best support my son with changes to his class next year?

Firstly, it is normal to worry about changes that lie ahead for our children and to worry about their ability to cope. You aren’t alone. The start of a new academic year is always full of changes to school life. New classrooms perhaps? Timetables? Teachers, pupils, curricula, canteen menus? You sound like you are holding a lot of anticipatory anxiety about the changes that are forthcoming. These changes have likely been explained to you by the school, and perhaps you still feel fearful?

How can I support my teen through a break up?

Apr 22, 2024

How can I support my teen through a break up?

Early teen romances can certainly feel exciting and exhilarating but most are also short-lived, and supporting our children through them is something we will likely have to do several times over the years to come. Here are some tips to help you to support your daughter.

How can I support my child’s move to a new school where he doesn’t know anyone?

Feb 13, 2024

How can I support my child’s move to a new school where he doesn’t know anyone?

Hello! Thanks for your question. When I was reading through it, the thing that stood out first was the description of your son as unconcerned about impending changes and “confident socially”. This is good news indeed and bodes well, although, as you suggest, it is prudent not to assume that he has zero concerns at all about the upcoming school move. 

What do we need to consider when buying our child a smartphone?

Aug 03, 2023

What do we need to consider when buying our child a smartphone?

First of all, well done considering this important decision ‘as a family’. Buying a first phone for a child can be a financial commitment but, truth be told, it’s also a decision that can impact on all aspects of their lives: mental health, wellbeing, resilience, friendships and even their learning. It is important to think of it as a significant decision which deserves research and reflection. A smartphone isn’t just a phone. Essentially, it is a hand-held computer that, once connected to the internet, can give access to a digital frontier occupied by five billion people.

What’s the best way to talk to my son about puberty and growing up?

Feb 17, 2023

What’s the best way to talk to my son about puberty and growing up?

We asked leading expert, Charlotte Markey, Professor of Psychology at Rutgers University, to answer this fantastic question from a Tooled Up mum. Charlotte has published numerous academic studies in this field and has also written two amazing books on body image for tweens and teens which we highly recommend. Details are at the bottom of the article.

How can I best support my son whilst my wife is going through treatment for breast cancer?

Sep 05, 2022

How can I best support my son whilst my wife is going through treatment for breast cancer?

Thank you for your question. From the detail you supply in your email to me, it is crystal clear that this young man lives in a loving, warm and supportive family unit (perfect conditions to cultivate and sustain a child’s resilience). Your concern relates to the fact that your child is starting secondary school and that his mother’s treatment coincides with an important milestone in his life. I can understand why, at this particular time, you might worry a little more about this child than other children in the family. 

How can I talk to my teenage daughter constructively about the clothes that she chooses to wear?

Jul 02, 2022

How can I talk to my teenage daughter constructively about the clothes that she chooses to wear?

First of all, you have my sympathy in dealing with this issue. The question you pose is not an easy one to grapple with, and I know for sure that it is a question on other parents’ minds too as summer approaches. Everyone wants their child to grow up to be independent, self-assured and body confident, but also to stay safe. So, your intentions in both raising this question and wanting to explore optimal ways for talking to your teen about her clothing choices, are well-placed and timely.

Schools and businesses

Let's get started

Get in touch